Skip to content

Paul Anthony Kelly Tattoos: His Misfits 138 Ink, Chest Tattoo and Arm Work

Paul Anthony Kelly’s tattoos are easy to miss when he’s dressed for a role. In Love Story, he played John F. Kennedy Jr. with a polished, old-school look. Away from the set, GQ reports that he has about 30 tattoos, including pieces he now finds too aggressive and one he plans to keep. The collection grew through different periods: punk music, modeling, travel and relationships.

The quick version

Kelly has said his “138” tattoo refers to the Misfits song “We Are 138.” He has also talked about regretting some older tattoos and considering removal. That mix of attachment and second thoughts is part of the story.

Photos show a chest tattoo peeking above a robe and larger pieces across both arms. They offer a few clear views, not a complete catalogue of every design.

The chest tattoo that peeks out of the robe

Paul Anthony Kelly tattoos: genuine tattoo evidence

A GQ Italia portrait shows a dark design high on Kelly’s chest, just above the neckline of a white robe. The crop only reveals part of it, so the full image and meaning can’t be identified. The dark lines break through the pale robe and chest hair. The placement can stay covered under ordinary clothes and show when he wears an open shirt or loose neckline.

The piece fits beneath a polished public look without disappearing from his own life. A chest tattoo can offer that choice, though the center of the chest is a sensitive spot for many people.

The arm tattoos are where the collection gets louder

Paul Anthony Kelly tattoos: genuine tattoo evidence

In a Zoom TV portrait, Kelly wears a white tank top that reveals a large shaded piece on one upper arm, with more ink on the other arm and upper chest. The main design is dark and graphic, with enough contrast to read from a distance.

If you’re planning a large arm piece, check how it looks from the front, side and back. The shoulder cap and tricep can change the shape once the design wraps around muscle; a flat reference won’t show that.

What “138” means to Kelly

“138” is the tattoo Kelly has singled out by name. It refers to the Misfits song “We Are 138,” a connection to the goth-punk music he has said he grew up loving. He has said he plans to keep this one.

A number can hold a private reference without spelling it out for everyone else. If you’re considering one, choose a date, song or other detail that already means something to you; the shape of the digits can come second.

The television role and the makeup chair

Paul Anthony Kelly in a contextual photograph: contextual only; not tattoo evidence; not tattoo evidence

This shirtless Love Story still is context, not a clear view of Kelly’s tattoos. It does show why the makeup team had work to do: his body art had to disappear when he played JFK Jr.

Covering dark ink for a period drama takes more than painting over it. The makeup artists had to neutralize the pigment, match his skin tone, blend the edges and make the cover-up hold under lights, movement and sweat. Kelly has described the process as a major part of his time in the makeup chair.

The career behind the look

Paul Anthony Kelly in a contextual photograph: contextual only; not tattoo evidence; not tattoo evidence

Kelly worked as a model for years before becoming widely known as an actor. In GQ, he described a goth-punk side—tight jeans and eyeliner—and the pressure to fit the image other people expected. The tattoos were one way to push back.

He has also said some pieces feel too aggressive for who he is now. Both can be true: a tattoo can belong to a real period in your life and later stop feeling like you. There’s no need to give every old decision a grand explanation.

Directions worth borrowing

  • A hidden chest tattoo: choose a spot that stays covered under everyday clothes and shows with an open neckline.
  • A bold upper-arm piece: let one design carry the weight if you plan to add more later.
  • A number with a real backstory: use a song, date or place you already care about.
  • A music reference: borrow the connection, not someone else’s exact tattoo or album art.
  • Room for change: leave space for future work and accept that your taste may shift.

What to ask for at the studio

Bring a clear idea of the subject and placement, then let the artist adjust it to your body. Ask to see how the design wraps around the muscle. Also ask how the lines and details may look as the tattoo ages; dense black areas can hold their shape, while tiny details may blur together.

If it’s a cover-up, show the artist what’s underneath and bring a healed photo if you have one. Be clear about why you want the new piece. Kelly’s “138” comes from his music history, but your reference should be yours.

Room for contradiction

Paul Anthony Kelly in a contextual photograph: contextual only; not tattoo evidence; not tattoo evidence

Kelly’s screen image can be a tuxedo, a sweater or a period costume; the tattoos belong to a different side of his life. He has talked openly about keeping some and regretting others. A person can change without every old tattoo becoming meaningless.

The photos don’t explain every design. Kelly’s own comments supply the clearest meaning; the rest can stay an open question.

More actor tattoo guides

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *